Monday, November 16, 2026

What Would You Do? Two Poker High Hand Situations from the Weekend

It has been quite some time since I made a blog post asking "What would you do?" Two situations this past weekend got me thinking that it would be interesting to hear different perspectives, since poker players often think so differently -- especially when it comes to sensitive topics like toking dealers and dealing with angry players. I am not going to post these situations on X, so if you'd like to weigh in, I would really appreciate it if you were to post your comments/ideas in the comments section of the blog. People on X will have no idea what you are referring to ... unless they have also read this post, of course! 😁

These are real life situations that happened at the poker table on November 14 and 15. For those of you who might not be familiar with my play, I am a recreational player who most often plays in $1/2, $1/3, and $2/3 No Limit games in my home poker rooms near Phoenix or on the road, mostly in Las Vegas.

Situation #1

On Saturday morning, I made the 50-minute drive to Gila River Resorts & Casinos - Lone Butte in Chandler, Arizona. Lone Butte runs a number of great promotions, many dealing with high hand bonuses -- my personal favorite. On Saturday, the promotion started at 11:00am. The first two 30-minute slots provided $2,500 high hand bonuses. After the first hour, the structure changed to 20 minutes and $1,000. I got to the casino shortly before 10:00am to make sure that I would be seated when the promo began. I was seated pretty quickly and, like many, was anticipating when the promo amount would change from the regular early morning $100 high hand to the first two $2,500 bonuses. I had been bleeding chips the my first hour of play -- even before the big bonuses kicked in. Once the important promo started, I was ready to go!

I was in a hand with one other player. To tell the truth, I don't even recall what I had. I decided to make a blind bet to $10 while the flop was being dealt. The flop was Q-Q-rag -- a flop that completely missed me. My opponent called. The turn also missed me and I checked. He put out a bet of $40 -- about twice the pot. I saw an obvious lost cause and folded. He turned over pocket Queens for quads. As this was only about the second hand we played since the $2,500 bonus started, he had to sweat out almost 30 minutes. Nobody had a higher hand, and this player got a rack of beautiful green chips delivered to the table. I was interested to see what he would toke the dealer. He did so, and play moved on. Several hours later, I was walking to the restroom, which is right outside the poker room, when I heard one player remarking on the amount of the toke. Word had apparently spread through the room.

This was a $1/2 game with most stacks in the $200-500 range. As far as I could tell, this player was a regular at Lone Butte.

So ... What would you do in this situation? You just won a $2,500 high hand. How much do you toke the dealer?


Situation #2

Sundays at The Arena Poker Room at Talking Stick Resort are fun days to play poker. Lots of recreational players at the resort for the weekend are playing, there is a high hand promo of $500 every 30 minutes, and there is also a football score ticket promotion that runs during the afternoon and evening games. For high hands, there has to be $30 in the pot. Only one hole card is required. I was playing in the $1/2 NL game, which has a max buy-in of ... $160! I was told this was to encourage new players to get in games.

Anyway, I was in the big blind with A-4os. There had been a raise to $7, and one player called. What the heck -- I threw in a red chip when it was my turn pre-flop. The flop: A-A-A! I thought I was stuck because of my four kicker. The pot had not yet hit the $30 mark, yet I had crappy kicker. I had forgotten that Talking Stick changed its rules several months earlier from two hole cards required to only one. More money got put in the pot, but I was still thinking that I wouldn't qualify for the bonus because I forgot about the change. Anyway, the turn was a seven and the river a six. Dummy me was internally bitching because I thought I didn't qualify for the high hand. I decided to bet $40 after the river. My opponent said "You don't have the case Ace, but must have a full house. I call." I am guessing he had a good full house. I turned my cards over and he got angry that I bet the $40 when the pot had already hit the $30 mark and it looked like I was going to win the $500 promo anyway. Mind you, this was mostly a "fun" recreational game with only a $160 max buy in. I was actually shocked that my A-A-A-A-7 hand went up on the board.

What would you say? What would you do? Anything? Nothing?

On the hope that some people will respond in the comments section of the blog (do so anonymously if you desire), I will wait several days before posting how both situations played out.

So ... tell me what you think! 😀

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home