What Would You Do? The Conclusion to My High Hand Poker Situations From Last Weekend
If You have not read the first post in this series, please read my post from Nov 15th first.
Situation #1
This dealt with the person who won the first high hand of the day at Gila River Resorts & Casinos - Lone Butte in Chandler, Arizona on Saturday, November 14. A player was next to me flopped quad Queens. Lucky for him that I was in the hand and made a blind $10 bet while the flop was being dealt -- smooth, tricky player that I am. 😁 Had I not done that, it is possible that the pot wouldn't have been big enough to qualify for the high hand. Anyway, the gentleman, whom I assume is a regular (old guy, had a friend at an adjacent table) was presented a beautiful rack of green chips. I was interested to see how much he would toke.
Like most poker players, I have some friends who are dealers. When I have asked them about tipping on high promos, they have answered with, what I believe, is a typical dealer answer: "I am thankful to receive any tips that players give me." After playing for many years, I decided that I would toke 5% on any high hands. Now ... once the amount starts getting high, I might adjust that slightly. 5% of $2,500 would be $125. I Imagine I would have toked a stack of reds -- $100, or 4%. The player who won the $2,500? He toked ... only $25 -- 1%! Nobody at the table (mostly a bunch of us "mature" gentlemen) said a thing. But word spread in the casino, as I heard a player leaving the poker room and mocking the amount that was toked.
I do not know the player who won the pot. I do not know his life situation. Regardless, I would have thought anybody should give more than $25.
Situation #2
I qualified for a $500 high hand but had forgotten that rules had changed. I was pissed that my flopped quad Aces only had a 4 kicker in my hand -- not realizing that only one card had to play instead of two hole cards -- the old requirement. An opponent who was in the hand (and helped me reach the $30 minimum pot that was required), got pissed when he called my $40 river bet, thinking that I was too greedy in what had been a fun game and table. The hand had to hold for almost 30 minutes, and with a busy day at The Arena Poker Room at Talking Stick Resort, that was not a given. As the clock was ticking down (and the opponent was S-L-O-W-L-Y calming down), I had plenty of time to think. My thoughts: 1) Had I realized that my quad Aces would make the board, I probably would have bet $20 on the river, thinking that might get a call. I was surprised that anyone at the table would call $40, but this guy had been bleeding chips. 2) The table had been ideal for me: at most, only one Talking Stick regular, friendly conversation, and passive play. I was doing quite well and didn't want to disrupt the flow. 3) We all know that feeling of frustration at the table. This was a cash game, not a tournament, so the give and take of chips in every hand isn't nearly that important.
I looked the guy straight in the eyes and said, "Do you want to know why I bet that?" He nodded yes. I said "I haven't played here much lately. The high hand rules changed some time ago. I thought I need to play both hole cards, and I was pissed that my quad Aces wouldn't qualify." That seemed to settle him down some. After the clock ticked down and I won the $500 (the dealer from that hand would get her 5%), I tossed four redbirds his way and said "If I had remembered the newer rules, I would have only bet $20. You can have this rebate."
Several things happened. I was admonished by the dealer for giving another players chips from my stack (oops). The players at the other end of the table were pleasantly surprised to see that table harmony had been restored. My opponent accepted the chips and settled down, eventually winning some chips off me when he flopped a set vs my pocket AA. He also won some other pots, so he was happy.
So ... was I foolish to give him $20? From an altruistic perspective, it was just $20 -- essentially a bigger bet in a small $1/2 game. It helped calm the guy down in what had been a friendly game. And I am just a recreational player playing in a recreational game. But, from a strategic perspective, it was a wise move. A weak player stayed in the game, table harmony was restored, and I believed that I profited some admiration from the other players. They seemed less likely to resent my stack, which had grown to three times the second highest stack. Along with the high hand promo, there was also a football promo going on. When the game ended, I cashed out a very nice profit.
Some people might like games where the players are adversarial. I prefer friendly games and I like the other players to see me as a nice guy. In this kind of environment, I tend to do well. That's not to say that I don't ever get pissy, in which case I can be a real a-hole at the table. But when that happens, I generally cash out. Life is too short and too good to spend time being angry.
Thanks for reading! I appreciated the comments on the initial post. Additional comments are welcomed on this one. Have a great poker weekend! 😎











